Advertise with us 
Order the new Progressive Rock For You Vol.1 CD Buy it here

 

 


 
:: Features ::
  Home
  News
  CD Reviews 08
  Interviews
 
New Release
  Special Feature
  Mp3's
  Concerts
  Gallery
   
  :: Resources ::
 
Best Links
 
Band Links
  Festivals
  Magazines 
  On Line Stores
  Record Labels


This web site is designed and maintained by
G.Roldan
Webmaster
reviewer
  



Click here to buy
this album





Best viewed at
 800 x 600
with Microsoft
Internet Explorer 7.0/Netscape


Click here
to donate  Prog4you.com







































































 


PROGENY
The Astoria
London, England
November 15th and 16th 2003
Concert review by Stephen Ellis

 
THE BANDS

  November 15th
Magenta
Richard Sinclair
In Cahoots
Kevin Ayers
Pallas
IQ
November 16th
Kevin Ayers
Arena (unplugged)
Mostly Autumn
The Enid
Pendragon
 
 
  DAY 1...

It was at NearFest 2003 that I first heard about the Progeny show in London. Another good friend and a lover of all things neo-prog, Allen Gunnison, who I had first met at NF 2000 and subsequently at Baja Prog in March of 2002 alerted me to this top notch lineup of mostly neo-prog or neo-prog styled bands.

Allen Gunnison did a most excellent article in the Spring/Summer 2003 Progression Magazine on some of the essential neo-prog recordings of the past 20 years to the present. As a side note, as a lover of all things neo-prog I realized I had all but three of the recordings Allen wrote about in his article. I have since found the three long out of print releases from that article that I did not have.

Anyway, Allen mentioned to me this event and I immediately got home and made hotel reservations and ordered our tickets. We were even able to get pretty good flight ticket prices.

Going to England for “just” the music show seemed like such a waste so JoAnn and I planned an extended week long ‘vacation’. As I had never actually taken a true vacation since I had graduated college back in 1976, this was going to be it. No cell phone, no laptop, just a pocket full of Travelers Checks.

Speaking of which, the US dollar to British Pound exchange rate is horrible. For every $200 in US funds exchanged you got around 125 British Pounds.

So we arrived early on November 11th and walked around London. On Wednesday the 12th we took the train about two hours north to a beautiful little town called Chesterfield. From there our friends picked us up and we drove to their home in the hills above Ashover, near Derbyshire.

Their home was built in 1703 and while it had been modernized over the years the feel was of a home with a tremendous amount of history.

We spent the night with Janet and Allan and had a wonderful visit. I walked out into the fields around their house that night. The sky was so clear and the stars were so bright and alive.

Over the next several days we went to a wonderful flea market in Chesterfield, drove on the wrong side of the road, enjoyed comfortable rides on the trains and even the tubes (their word for the subway). The cabbies were fun and friendly and the food was not bad. I fell in love with this stuff called Brown Sauce and English meat pies. The great beers were not bad either. In fact, I soon learned that you do not drink beer as much as you eat it as most are so wonderfully thick and full bodied.

Ultimately we met some wonderful people who had come in from different parts of England just for this show. It seems that as far as London goes, prog shows are far from common.

Anyway we met John, Jenny, David and Miles who were also neo-prog heads and were also in town for the Neal Morse show on the Friday before Progeny.

Jo and I had walked to this little pub called Jack Horner’s to have a Guinness and a snack before heading to the Neal Morse show and here was this table of cool looking people. The first thing I noticed was one guy with a Steve Hackett tour shirt, another with a Flower Kings tour shirt and Jenny had on a Spock’s Beard tour shirt. Of course, noticing these shirts I asked if they were in town for Neal Morse and Progeny and they were. As is typical of the vast majority of prog music fans I have ever met, this group was immediately friendly and invited us Yanks to sit down and visit. We had barely set down before John had taken our beer orders and the evening was on.

In addition to this group of “locals” there were at least five friends we knew from US prog shows that had flown across the pond for this event. Also, an internet friend, Frode from Norway, was in attendance. As I’ve said in the past about these music shows, it is really like a friendly family reunion.

Another quick point to make is that Progeny was in no way meant to be anything like ProgDay, NearFest, ProgFest, ProgWest, or even Baja Prog. No, Progeny was a weekend event scheduled a club. In/out was only allowed up to a certain time of the evening, no food/drinks allowed in, and basically no real music vendors, etc. Progeny was just a weekend of music.

The Astoria is a famous London venue that has played host to numerous prog shows in the past and still manages to book a very eclectic group of bands including Spock’s Beard, Porcupine Tree, and many others.

The venue holds at least 2000 people and this weekend event was well attended as would be expected.

First up on Saturday was Magenta. A band from Wales that I had really wanted to see, I was somewhat upset that even before the doors had been opened and all the people waiting in line had made their way into the venue, Magenta had already started. This band is excellent. A very fluid style of prog that while not truly “neo-prog” it certainly has a melodic and symphonic sound that should warm the heart of any prog lover who prefers melody and song structure to noodling.
 


Magenta has a wonderful female lead singer whose voice was as clear as a bell and heart wrenching. This was no Annie Haslam want to be as her voice was truly her own. She wore a long spaghetti strapped black dress and was barefoot during the entire set.

A most excellent opening band that should have been given more time to play.

The Carl Palmer Band who was scheduled to play had to drop out as one band member had developed a severe case of tinnitus (ringing in the ears) and had to be away from music for a period of time.

To my mind and others the promoters should have added some time to Magenta and to Pallas but that did not happen. I’ll explain more later.

Each band used their own gear so the stage was packed and layered with rig after rig. I was sure that there was no way they would be able to change bands along the time line they had set forth but they sure did. All weekend long they moved from one band to the next in seamless fashion.

Next up was Richard Sinclair. I had not really realized exactly who this guy was until I heard his voice. Then I realized he was the original singer in Camel (I believe he sang on Camel’s first two releases) then he moved on to play and sing with Caravan.

His set was very mellow and laid back. Just him on acoustic guitar and one other person playing flute and sax. Not a bad set just not enough energy to get the crowd worked up. It was clear that on this day the crowd was here to see two bands. Those were Pallas and IQ.

Following Richard Sinclair was the Canterbury/Fusion band called In Cahoots. In Cahoots is exactly the type of music I do not like. The band is full of extremely talented musicians who simply prefer noodling to song structure.



A band that feels it’s more important to see exactly how many notes they can cram into a three minute song as the more notes the better right?

They left me and a vast majority of this ever increasing crowd cold. I was very glad when their set ended.

Next up was Pallas. Ah Pallas. This is one of the bands I was coming to see even though I knew they were only going to get to play a shortened set due to allowing more time for the Carl Palmer Band prior to IQ.

To make it worse, The Carl Palmer Band had to drop out as one band member had developed a severe case of tinnitus (ringing in the ears). Rather than ask Pallas to play longer, the promoters asked Kevin Ayers to add a set on Saturday.

Pallas ROCKED THE HOUSE. They reminded the very loving crowd exactly why it is called Prog ROCK. Pallas was so tight; they played as if they had not missed a day of playing in twenty years. They played songs from The Cross and The Crucible, they played classic songs from both of their earliest releases and as the icing on the cake they concluded their abbreviated set with Sanctuary.

Man, they rocked the house. I could have listened to them for hours.



After another rapid set change, on came Kevin Ayers. Kevin Ayers was a member of the original Soft Machine but was only on their very first LP. I suppose that is the link that got him invited to play this gig.

But why oh why was he ever invited to play? I’m sorry, but this guy did not deserve to be part of this event. His music was pure and simply what I would call “rockabilly”. It was just so out of place at this event. To make it worse, all of the songs sounded exactly alike. The only real difference was the lyrics that were in each song. The one song that really got me was one he called “Super Salesman”. In this song one of the lines was “…I’m a super salesman, I can make you buy all the crap I am selling.” Yep, he was selling crap but most of the crowd was back at the bar with only a handful standing anywhere near the stage.

His only saving grace was the most beautiful Electric Blue Fender Stratocaster he was playing. Like it was the prettiest guitar I’ve ever seen, of course I’m very partial to blue. Also, his band had another lead guitar player who could have passed as Phil Lynot the late guitarist from Thin Lizzy. Not that he could play that good but he sure looked like Phil.

Certainly there was no call for this guy to be asked to fill in on Saturday. The promoters should have extended both the Magenta and the Pallas sets.

The final band on Saturday was IQ. These guys were given a full two hours and used it to the hilt. They brought their full on show including projectors, film, and special lighting.



IQ came to impress and did exactly that. They played old familiar sings from The Wake, Subterrania, Seventh House and even a few new tunes. John Jowett rocked as usual; Peter Nichols (while fighting a cold) sang his heart out and was a clear and powerful stage presence. Martin Orford showed why he is the Master keyboardist that he is. Paul Cook rocked on drums and Mike Holmes with his trademark “Monty Python” salute simply ripped on guitar.

What a great evening of neo-prog music.

After the show Jo and I were hauled off to a lovely little Indian restaurant just around the corner from the venue. The Pallas guys were also there and we enjoyed a wonderful meal of loud taunts and warm beer.

As Pallas was leaving they did tell us that the promoters had done well financially and that there would be a Progeny II in 2004.
 


Next Page  ]

 

PROGENY
 




 

                                                    
                                  :: Site Info ::
                              Affiliation  -  Contact - Feedback - Prog4you.com Staff